How to choose a hand in American mahjong
Don't pick one hand right after the deal. Sort your 13 tiles, see what stands out, such as pairs, even numbers, odd numbers, numbers in a row or winds, and choose the section of the card that uses those tiles. Then narrow to one hand, or a first choice and a backup, during the Charleston, as the passes show you which tiles you are actually getting.
Pick a section, not a hand
The card is split into sections, such as hands of even numbers, odd numbers, numbers in a row, and winds and dragons. In our study of how YouTube teachers teach this, four of the five teachers who cover it suggest choosing a section first and a single hand later.
- Southern Sparrow goes with “what jumps out at you first” and asks four questions of a sorted rack: many winds? many evens? many odds? numbers in a row?
- Ladies That Mahj uses “when in doubt, count it out”: count your even and odd tiles and lean toward the larger group. Odd tiles are more common, so a lead of one or two odd tiles means little (see below).
- Mah Jongg Class goes down the card one section at a time, counting how many of your tiles fit each.
Pairs and triples matter more than lone tiles. Mah Jongg Class calls them your strength: two or three of the same tile are much closer to a group than one is.
What a dealt rack usually looks like
We counted every possible 13-tile deal from the 152 tiles our game uses, then checked the numbers against 50,000 games dealt by the game itself.
- 83% of 13-tile racks start with at least one pair. Two flowers count, because all flowers play alike.
- 8% start with three of a kind.
- The average rack has about 5 odd-numbered tiles and 4 even ones, because each suit has five odd numbers (1, 3, 5, 7, 9) and four even ones (2, 4, 6, 8).
- 48% of racks get no joker at all. The joker odds page has the full table.
So a pair on your rack is normal, and a small lean toward odd numbers is normal too. It takes a bigger gap, or several pairs in one section, before a rack really points somewhere.
Then narrow to one hand
Once almost all your tiles fit one section, go back to the card and count how many you hold toward each hand in it. Southern Sparrow commits when the count reaches six or more.
Michele Frizzell shows three styles. The fixed style picks one hand before the first pass and keeps to it. The adaptive style keeps every tile that fits the section and narrows only when there are no spare tiles left to pass. The hybrid stays adaptive through the Charleston and fixes on one hand for play. Learn Mah Jongg from a Mentor names switching hands after a few picks as a common beginner mistake, which is a good reason to settle by the end of the Charleston.
Practice on your own
Southern Sparrow gives viewers homework: deal yourself 13 tiles, choose a section, and work through the passes alone. Our practice card has hands written for learning, so you can try this without the official card, and the computer game lets you play a full hand from your choice.
Common questions
When should you pick your hand in American mahjong?
Choose a section of the card after the deal and pick the exact hand during or just after the Charleston. Southern Sparrow's rule of thumb is to commit once six or more of your tiles fit one hand.
Should you switch hands during a game?
Not often. Tiles you passed or discarded for the first hand are gone, and the new hand may need them. Learn Mah Jongg from a Mentor tells beginners to choose one hand and stay with it, win or lose.
Do jokers make it easier to choose a hand?
They make it harder to read, because a joker fits almost any group of three or more. Choose your section from the real tiles and treat the jokers as help for whatever you pick.
